Democrats are confident about the Senate matchups despite the “challenging map”

Democrats are confident about the Senate matchups despite the "challenging map"
Getty Images

Following Tuesday’s primaries, the Senate landscape is established, and both parties are preparing for a close, costly struggle for control that will revolve around a few crucial states.

Following their respective victories in Florida’s red state’s general election—GOP Sen. Rick Scott and Democratic former Representative Debbie Mucarsel-Powell—the major November Senate elections are finally set, with the majority taking place in Democratic-held territory.

Join our Channel

Thanks to the newfound fervor that Vice President Kamala Harris’s candidacy has generated and the strength of the reputations that the incumbent senators have established in their home states, Democrats are feeling hopeful that they can cling onto their slim majority. However, Republicans continue to believe that the odds are more in their favor and are wagering that in swing states that are crucial to win, voters’ partisan allegiance will triumph over Democrats’.

Because the vice president casts tiebreaking votes in the Senate, Republicans only need to gain two seats net to win an outright majority—or just one if former President Donald Trump wins the presidency.

Sen. Joe Manchin, a Democrat from a strongly conservative state in West Virginia, decided not to seek reelection, thus the GOP can practically already mark one victory in their column. And Sens. Jon Tester of Montana and Sherrod Brown of Ohio, two states that Trump easily won four years ago, are the GOP’s two main targets.

“To maintain their majority, the Senate Democrats must deliver a flawless performance, not only in Ohio but also in ruby red Montana,” stated National Republican Senatorial Committee Chairman Steve Daines, a Republican from Montana, in a statement. “We’re happy with our odds.”

The Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee veteran Martha McKenna retorted, saying, “Although the geography may be challenging, our starting pitchers are among the finest in the team, to use an overused metaphor.”

McKenna later said, “We’ve had five or six perfect innings.” “And we just need to close now.”

Partisanship vs. incumbency

Sen. Gary Peters, a Democrat from Michigan and the chairman of the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, stated in a recent interview that although West Virginia is no longer in contention, he thinks his party can hold 50 seats. However, he continued, expressing his “strong optimism” that Democrats will win one or two Republican-held seats in Florida and Texas.

In order to achieve that, Tester and Brown will probably need to pull off something few in the divisive Trump era have managed to do: win their states while the electorate backs a presidential candidate from the opposition party. In 2020, only Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine) managed to accomplish it. Furthermore, in 2016, no Senate contender did so.

However, Democrats think those two senators have the ability to convince voters to split their tickets.

According to Peters, “Their constant need has been to rise above the Democratic base.” “They have already carried it out. I have no doubt that they will repeat the action in the future.

The force of incumbency has been as potent as partisan polarization. The 2022 midterm elections resulted in the reelection of all senators. 2020 saw five losses, compared to only two in 2016.

However, Democrats face a difficult task in keeping not only those two red states but also a number of other states that have historically been close calls, such as Pennsylvania, Nevada, Arizona, Wisconsin, and Michigan. They also intend to personalize the conflict.

‘Voters will evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of the two candidates they have selected,” Peters stated later. “We have strong Democratic incumbents and contenders facing weak Republican opponents.” And we have no doubt that after they do that, they will support the Democratic senatorial candidate.

This month, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee has released a barrage of advertisements questioning the connections between the GOP candidates and the states they are running in, probing their financial histories and personal histories.

However, Republicans point to candidates with military experience such as Dave McCormick of Pennsylvania and Tim Sheehy of Montana as evidence that they think they have good recruiters. In addition to being personally affluent, those two Republicans and the other candidates can finance their own campaigns in the face of an overwhelming amount of Democratic funding.

Local vs. national focus

The GOP has attempted to nationalize the campaign while Democrats have attempted to make it more regional and personal.

In a series of advertisements, the National Republican Senatorial Committee has collaborated with Republican contenders to link Democrats to Harris and President Joe Biden. (The advertisements are called hybrid advertising, and they have to touch on national concerns in part.)

With the addition of fresh volunteers and campaign funds, Democratic Senate candidates have received a much-needed energy boost from Harris’ new position as the front-runner for the presidency.

Prior to his decision to withdraw from the race, public polls had shown that Democratic Senate contenders were outperforming Biden. Even while there are still others who outpace Harris, their pathways are less hazy at the top of the ticket.

The Democratic strategist McKenna stated, “Even before the transition, I believe we had great matchups, but now it seems like everyone is drinking Red Bull.”

A youthful, vibrant candidate running for president has created “extraordinary vigor among Democrats and Independents alike,” according to Peters, who also noted that Harris’ rise has sparked this enthusiasm. Thus, that will undoubtedly benefit everyone.

Democrats may find more support from this fervor if they try to extend the Senate battleground to Florida, where Scott is running for a second term against Mucarsel-Powell, and Texas, where Republican Sen. Ted Cruz faces Democratic Rep. Colin Allred.

Democrats have not committed a substantial amount of resources to either state thus far, according to ad tracking company AdImpact. Peters isn’t discounting it, though.

“It’s obvious that keeping all of our Democratic incumbent seats is my top priority, and that’s where the majority of our current investments are going,” Peters declared. “However, we also want to attack, and we’ll invest when we spot opportunities.”

On the other hand, Republicans argue that despite the change at the top of the ballot, the race for the Senate has not changed significantly.

Republican strategist Josh Holmes, a former chief of staff to Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., stated, “I think that this Senate picture is remarkably stable, although there’s been a lot of changes in the last six to eight weeks in the national environment.”

Holmes pointed out that Republicans have not repeated their mistakes from 2022 by attempting to redraw the Senate’s boundaries, instead remaining focused on their important pickup possibilities.

Holmes stated, “From our perspective, we knew that it’s just going to be a dogfight the whole way.” He also mentioned that outside organizations, party committees, and campaigns had “prepared as though this is a fight to get to 55 or 60, not a fight to win one seat, two seats, or three seats.”

Given that Republican former governor Larry Hogan has a track record of winning the deep blue state, Republicans are nonetheless cautiously hopeful about their chances in Maryland. Though they had been considering a few potential targets in Democratic-leaning states such as New Mexico, that avenue is less viable in the absence of Biden undermining his fellow Democrats.

A GOP strategist with experience in Senate contests, who asked to remain anonymous to talk about party strategy, stated, “An atmosphere with the wind at your back is necessary.” “And I don’t think we’re at that place right now.”

Democrats further down the ballot have shown a greater willingness to campaign with their presidential contender when Harris is at the top of the ticket.

During the early days of Harris’ campaign, she was joined at her rallies by Democratic senators Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin, Bob Casey of Pennsylvania, and Jacky Rosen of Nevada; moreover, she was joined by Representatives Elissa Slotkin of Michigan and Ruben Gallego of Arizona, who were all competing for open seats.

Republican contenders for the Senate have long ties to Trump. With the exception of Hogan, every leading contender gave a speech at the Republican conference last month, demonstrating how strongly their opposition to Trump is linked.

“There are a number of extremely close races in which voters’ ultimate decision will be whether they approve of the current state of affairs or wish to return to the economic conditions of 2016, 2017, 2018, and 2019,” stated Holmes.

Republicans think that worries about crime, immigration, and living expenses will benefit them across the board. Moreover, Democrats regard abortion as a major national issue, which may help Senate candidates in states like Florida, Arizona, and Nevada where ballot initiatives to codify safeguards for abortion rights are on the ballot.

Nonetheless, Democrats continue to recognize that a difficult battle is ahead.

According to a Democratic strategist working in Senate elections, “it’s a challenging map.” “The map will remain difficult until Election Day.”

Leave a comment